Is this the most controversial image of the Twenty-First Century?
- Text by Shelley Jones
- Photography by Giovanni Troilo
Awards are usually courted by a fair amount of controversy. In fact that’s mostly what they’re good for. You get a whole industry, and surrounding community, to sort of analyse where a subject’s at and usually some great issues are addressed, some great conclusions are made.
And so the World Press Photo awards have fulfilled their duty to photojournalism this year in sparking a great debate about ethics and honesty in the discipline. The catalyst? This striking NSFW image by Italian photographer Giovanni Troilo.
Submitted to the awards as part of his series The Dark Heart of Europe, Troilo claimed this image of a painter and his subjects was shot in Charleroi, Belgium, where the whole series was claimed to have been shot. Independent investigations have since revealed that the image was in fact shot in Molenbeek, in Brussels. More damning still, is the accusation that many of the photos in Troilo’s award-winning collection are also staged.
Troilo admits the location details were wrong, claiming an honest mistake, but vehemently denies staging any of the images. The World Press Photo awards have since withdrawn Troilo’s prize amid growing pressure from the photojournalism community – a respected French photojournalism festival Visa Pour L’Image went as far as to ban any World Press Photos from its festival this year to protest the prize.
Whether Troilo made a mistake or he intentionally misled his audience is up for debate. What’s interesting is how difficult that will be to prove either way. All photography carries an element of ambiguity to it. There is no such thing as a truly honest photograph. Every part of the process, from what the photographer chooses to capture and what they choose to omit, to the wants and desires of the subject, and the stance of their editor. There are multiple truths and you cannot represent them all in one image.
“All photography is fiction,” Joerg Colberg, who runs Conscientious, an editorial website about contemporary fine-art photography, once wrote in British Journal of Photography. “As a photographer you make choices, which influence the photograph enough for it to be more of a fiction than a fact. That’s photography for you. That’s just the way it is. But the photojournalist’s task, no actually the photojournalist’s duty is to minimise the amount of fiction that enters her/his photography. We are quite aware of the problem in the news context, so we expect photographs in this context to be as truthful as they can be.”
In the second documentary photography special issue of Huck, released in October last year, photography writer Oliver Laurent commented that: “A work of fiction can be as powerful, if not more, as reality.” But quoted photographer Tom Jamieson in saying as long as “you’re open with it”.
Even Lars Boering, who recently took over as managing director of World Press Photo, is acknowledging the grey areas. “We have to look hard at the ways photography is changing,” Boering told BJP yesterday, March 5. “It seems some people are confused about what journalism is and where documentary photography starts. Everybody is talking about art photography [in which images can be manipulated and staged with no issue] but while documentary photography can be art, it is not by definition [the same thing]. To go from documentary photography to art is a big step, and there needs to be a step in between which is about personal storytelling. That is a whole new area, and a very interesting and exciting one, but we have to understand its relationship to photojournalism in a more traditional sense.”
It might not be suitable for the prize, but it seems Troilo’s photograph is challenging us all to reconsider the definitions of truth and objectivity in images in general, which can only be a good thing.
Careful what you believe.
Latest on Huck
This erotic zine dismantles LGBTQ+ respectability politics
Zine Scene — Created by Megan Wallace and Jack Rowe, PULP is a new print publication that embraces the diverse and messy, yet pleasurable multitudes that sex and desire can take.
Written by: Isaac Muk
As Tbilisi’s famed nightclubs reawaken, a murky future awaits
Spaces Between the Beats — Since Georgia’s ruling party suspended plans for EU accession, protests have continued in the capital, with nightclubs shutting in solidarity. Victor Swezey reported on their New Year’s Eve reopening, finding a mix of anxiety, catharsis and defiance.
Written by: Victor Swezey
Los Angeles is burning: Rick Castro on fleeing his home once again
Braver New World — In 2020, the photographer fled the Bobcat Fire in San Bernardino to his East Hollywood home, sparking the inspiration for an unsettling photo series. Now, while preparing for its exhibition, he has had to leave once again, returning to the mountains.
Written by: Miss Rosen
Ghais Guevara: “Rap is a pinnacle of our culture”
What Made Me — In our new series, we ask artists and rebels about the forces and experiences that have shaped who they are. First up, Philadelphian rap experimentalist Ghais Guevara.
Written by: Ghais Guevara
Gaza Biennale comes to London in ICA protest
Art and action — The global project, which presents the work of over 60 Palestinian artists, will be on view outside the art institution in protest of an exhibition funded by Bloomberg Philanthropies.
Written by: Cyna Mirzai
Ragnar Axelsson’s thawing vision of Arctic life
At the Edge of the World — For over four decades, the Icelandic photographer has been journeying to the tip of the earth and documenting its communities. A new exhibition dives into his archive.
Written by: Cyna Mirzai