The Affected Ones: Why French teenagers are joining ISIS
- Text by Cian Traynor
- Illustrations by Oliver Stafford
“We’ve never seen anything like this before,” says Farhad Khosrokhavar, an Iranian-born sociologist specialising in teenage radicalisation. “This is something brand new to Europe.”
Khosrokhavar is the author of books such as Inside Jihadism as well as being the director of studies at l’EHESS, a leading social science institution in Paris.
That background has helped establish connections with French adolescents who have absconded to Syria and Iraq. Some have stayed in touch with family members; others were prevented from leaving in the first place and are now in custody or under supervision.
Through relatives of those teenagers as well as associates within France’s Ministry of the Interior, Khosrokhavar has been able to investigate 30 to 40 cases (excluding secondary research) in order to better understand the phenomenon.
The demographic
Approximately 5,000 Westerners have joined the Islamic State, Khosrokhavar says, and about 600-700 of them are female. But in France, roughly half of all those joining ISIS between the ages of 12 and 17 are girls. They are mainly from middle-class backgrounds, with around 30 per cent having no connection with Islam.
“Most of them are not religious,” says Khosrokhavar. “They are ‘the affected ones’. What’s important for many of them is to become adults. It’s a shortcut to adulthood. They know that once they’re there, people here will be fearful of them, first of all.
“They see that as an adult characteristic: people respect you or at least don’t look down at you in a condescending way. Through their journey to Syria, they believe they’re achieving that – and partially that’s true. Just getting there is another way of asserting their accelerated adulthood. It’s what anthropologists call a ‘rite of passage.’”
The domino effect
The urge to flee is often sparked by a friend, relative or boyfriend who has already left for the Middle East, Khosrokhavar says. A simple call encouraging them to come can prove powerful and, if convinced, a streamlined conversion to Islam can be facilitated in under two weeks.
Normally two adult Muslims are required to witness the convert’s ‘shahada’, or declaration of faith, though Twitter posts have been used to circumvent this.
“They’re more interested in getting over there than becoming competent in Islam,” says Khosrokhavar. “Sometimes parents don’t even know about [the conversion]. It’s so rapid that they don’t have the time to understand what’s going on or to do anything about it.”
The online ecosystem
Social media platforms like Twitter and ask.fm are integral to the recruitment process. Since the summer of 2014, ISIS has made a concentrated effort to lure foreign women into its ranks.
The Islamic State presents itself as a social movement dedicated to protecting Muslims while combating an imbalance of global power. It does so while cultivating an open community online where isolated or disenchanted figures can easily connect with support, encouragement and advice.
The disconnect
The parents of Aqsa Mahmood, for example – a teenager who fled Scotland for Syria – believe she was ‘groomed’ online to marry a Jihadist. Now 21 and using the adopted name Umm Layth, she has since distributed a step-by-step guide to help other Westerners follow her path.
“The first phone call you make once you cross the borders is one of the most difficult things you will ever have to do,” it reads. “When you hear them sob and beg like crazy on the phone for you to come back, it’s so hard.”
Khosrokhavar believes we’re seeing the first generation of females who have the same fascination for violence as young men. But with the exception of those who join the al-Khansa Brigade – an all-female enforcement squad – their goals rarely extend beyond marrying a jihadist fighter and beginning a family.
“They believe the relationships here are not serious and cannot be solidly built with the young, immature boys who surround them,” Khosrokhavar says. “It’s more the idea of a romanticised, exotic world rather than any direct identification with Islam. They feel that they can be helpful over there and build a new type of life.”
The reality check
Though many embrace their new circumstances – even re-marrying after the death of a husband – others struggle to adapt.
There’s an initial shock, Khosrokhavar says, among those who are placed in a common house and face heavy restrictions until they get married. Often this will be with another European, so that they can communicate better, but frustration and depression are common among the cases Khosrokhavar has seen.
“Some of them become disgusted,” he says. “After a while, they feel they cannot cope with it and would like to return. But that’s not easy, as most of the time their passport is taken by the authorities.”
The fallout
Earlier this month, two teenage girls disappeared from their school in the French alps only to resurface after unsuccessfully attempting to join the Islamic State in Syria.
In a subsequent report by the Associated French Press, one academic likened the appeal of this jihadi-bride subculture to punk rock – a comparison Khosrokhavar is wary of.
While it’s true that these teens have a transgressive attitude, he says, they also identify with puritanical and repressive ideals – a far cry from the way punk put social norms into question.
What the phenomenon does bring under scrutiny, Khosrokhavar says, is the diluting family unit. He sees the role of technology in adolescents’ lives as beginning to eclipse parental authority, allowing ISIS to draw from western Europe in ways that al-Qaeda never could.
“Before 2013, you didn’t have any major case of migration to a country at war,” he says. “We know there are lots of restrictions over there for girls and women – yet in spite of that, there’s a fascination and excitement for the adventure this Daesh-type society represents. So in a way, it’s a mirror of our own society and its inability to give some sort of political utopia to younger generations who feel totally disillusioned and disenchanted.”
Enjoyed this article? Like Huck on Facebook or follow us on Twitter.
Latest on Huck
This erotic zine dismantles LGBTQ+ respectability politics
Zine Scene — Created by Megan Wallace and Jack Rowe, PULP is a new print publication that embraces the diverse and messy, yet pleasurable multitudes that sex and desire can take.
Written by: Isaac Muk
As Tbilisi’s famed nightclubs reawaken, a murky future awaits
Spaces Between the Beats — Since Georgia’s ruling party suspended plans for EU accession, protests have continued in the capital, with nightclubs shutting in solidarity. Victor Swezey reported on their New Year’s Eve reopening, finding a mix of anxiety, catharsis and defiance.
Written by: Victor Swezey
Los Angeles is burning: Rick Castro on fleeing his home once again
Braver New World — In 2020, the photographer fled the Bobcat Fire in San Bernardino to his East Hollywood home, sparking the inspiration for an unsettling photo series. Now, while preparing for its exhibition, he has had to leave once again, returning to the mountains.
Written by: Miss Rosen
Ghais Guevara: “Rap is a pinnacle of our culture”
What Made Me — In our new series, we ask artists and rebels about the forces and experiences that have shaped who they are. First up, Philadelphian rap experimentalist Ghais Guevara.
Written by: Ghais Guevara
Gaza Biennale comes to London in ICA protest
Art and action — The global project, which presents the work of over 60 Palestinian artists, will be on view outside the art institution in protest of an exhibition funded by Bloomberg Philanthropies.
Written by: Cyna Mirzai
Ragnar Axelsson’s thawing vision of Arctic life
At the Edge of the World — For over four decades, the Icelandic photographer has been journeying to the tip of the earth and documenting its communities. A new exhibition dives into his archive.
Written by: Cyna Mirzai