Review: Sherpa by Jennifer Peedom — The death of 16 Sherpas on Everest in 2014 went almost unnoticed by foreign climbers. But the tragedy helped the long-mistreated Nepalese guides to find their voice.

In the summer of 2014, Mount Everest experienced what was at the time the worst mountaineering tragedy in its history. When an avalanche struck and killed sixteen Sherpa guides, filmmaker Jennifer Peedom inadvertently ended up documenting a groundbreaking moment in Sherpa history. She was there to shoot an exploration into developing unrest between native Nepalese Sherpas and the hundreds of glory-seeking tourists they guide up Mount Everest every summer. But it wasn’t until the cameras started rolling that her film became something radically different.

With conflict already in the air, the deaths of the guides had brought to the surface inequalities and long-standing oppression in the relationship between Sherpas and the westerners they annually endure. Long having been witness to a holy place morph into an overcrowded tourist trap, amplified by low pay, high risks and ill treatment, the Sherpas were over it. So they decided to strike, realising their presence can make or break an entire industry.

Through archive footage and first-hand testimony, Sherpa explores a people historically mistreated, undermined and depicted as colonial ornaments, expected to fulfil the cliché of grinning subservience. Context is granted in the form of Tenzing Norgay, depicted as a cheerful if mostly silent Sherpa celebrity after guiding the first successful Everest ascent in 1953. But the inequality he experienced at the time, including being awarded the second-tier George Medal instead of the Knighthoods afforded his white peers, seemed to set a precedent for future treatment.

Peedom’s narrative, however, recognises a generational shift. One of the first generations to experience traditional education, along with forms of activism and rebellion via the internet, young Sherpas are vocal, expressive and self-actualising in a way that their predecessors couldn’t be. The only individuals able to withstand crippling altitudes and guide a safe path for western climbers, they recognise how fundamental they are to the industry, along with the power they actually wield.

Sherpa 2

White faces permeate the film, though outside of occasional contextual narration from writer Ed Douglas, they are almost universally villainous. Russell Brice, manager of the mountaineering company at the heart of the story, is a strange one. He expresses empathy and appears to care deeply for the Sherpas in his employ, but distorts the truth and later outwardly lies in order to suppress group tension. Preferring a fence-sitting approach rather than properly addressing the Sherpa strikes, he’s a fascinating contradiction of very human compassion and capitalist exploitation.

Certain western mountaineers glimpsed here and there are also inexplicably shameful. One chastises the “owners” of the Sherpas for not keeping them in line once they launch a strike, others treat the 16 deaths as little more than a burden spoiling their expedition.

Peedom’s direction is both tense and subtle, as if her camera is weaving into secret conversations, where characters become stoic and strong, or alternatively hang themselves with expressions of shocking ignorance. She’s accompanied by Sam Petty’s masterful sound design, never better than in the film’s central avalanche – a thundering, guttural boom so intense that it momentarily blacks out the screen.

Along with The Hunting Ground and Black Panthers: Vanguard of the Revolution, Sherpa is another 2015 documentary depicting minority voices fighting against forms of oppression. It’s an important, relevant theme granted even more credence by the film’s depiction of the scale and majesty of the mountain itself. Often photographed in sweeping, panoramic shots supplied by cinematographer Renan Ozturk, it is grand and cinematic in a way that contrasts nicely with the more ragged, handheld quality that takes over once the strike kicks in.

Worshipped by the Nepalese people, the community views Everest as mother nature in its purest form – they pray to her, expect respect for her, and treat the Sherpa deaths as symbolic of her demands for change. One scene depicts a fight breaking out when a foreign climber launches into an expletive-ridden tirade while climbing, unaware of the spiritual significance of the mountain. It might sound dramatic on paper, but watching Sherpa, you can’t help but become a believer yourself.

Sherpa is in cinemas from December 15, and will be broadcast globally on Discovery Channel in 2016.

Latest on Huck

Meet Corbin Shaw, Huck 81’s Artist in Residence
Huck 81

Meet Corbin Shaw, Huck 81’s Artist in Residence

The Sheffield born artist talks about the people and places that shaped his practice for the latest issue of Huck.

Written by: Josh Jones

The Blessed Madonna: “Dance music flourishes in times of difficulty”
Photography

The Blessed Madonna: “Dance music flourishes in times of difficulty”

The DJ talks about her debut album ‘Godspeed’, connection and resistance on the dance floor, the US election and more alongside exclusive pictures from her album release party.

Written by: Ben Smoke

Revisiting the birth of skate culture in 1970s Los Angeles
Photography

Revisiting the birth of skate culture in 1970s Los Angeles

New photobook ‘Last Days of Summer: California Skateboarding Archive 1975–1978’ looks back at an iconic chapter of youth culture.

Written by: Miss Rosen

An unnerving portrait of the USA’s fractured society
Photography

An unnerving portrait of the USA’s fractured society

A new photobook explores America’s increasing inequality, division and toxic culture wars in a historic election year.

Written by: Isaac Muk

“Music can save you for a day”: Touché Amoré on social media and subcultures
Music

“Music can save you for a day”: Touché Amoré on social media and subcultures

To celebrate a new album and reflect on a decade and a half of being themselves, frontman Jeremy Bolm chats about opening up via lyrics, subcultures in the internet age, and the hardcore re-revival.

Written by: Isaac Muk

Meet the Paratriathlete who cheated death twice
Outdoors

Meet the Paratriathlete who cheated death twice

A near fatal training crash ruined British Paralympian George Peasgood’s Paris 2024 plans. As he recovers, his life and outlook are changing – will LA 2028 be part of his future?

Written by: Sheridan Wilbur

Sign up to our newsletter

Issue 81: The more than a game issue

Buy it now